Listed in order of year elected. An asterisk (*) denotes a past president who has died.
- 1958 Harris Stevens *
- 1959 Alvin J. Keller
- 1960 Roy E. Anderson
- 1961 Donald C. Duranso *
- 1962 Jack W. Loftus *
- 1963 William J. Tacey, Jr.
- 1964 James H. Bolerjack, Jr.
- 1965 Ruby Geary *
- 1966 G. Edward Harris *
- 1967 Don L. Viane
- 1968 Dean A. Porter
- 1969 Betty Schmidt *
- 1970 M.O. Elliott
- 1971 Gerald Morrow
- 1972 Calvin Henry *
- 1973 Duane Blietz *
- 1974 Kenneth A. Klein
- 1975 Darlene Heroz
- 1976 Peg Grell
- 1977 Sylvia Gross
- 1978 James J. Kelly *
- 1979 Glendon M. Kiger *
- 1980 Kenneth M. Bonder *
- 1981 Richard L. Jesse *
- 1982 Joseph J. DeMichiel
- 1983 George Coney
- 1984 Edward F. Hosek *
- 1985 Keith Wendland *
- 1986 Dennis Lauer *
- 1987 Ronald J. Hill
- 1988 George Valentine *
- 1989 Daniel Ryan
- 1990 David Jepson *
- 1991 Doug Ellsworth
- 1992 Gregory Peters
- 1993 Hella Tomczak
- 1994 Beth Couter
- 1995 Leonard Flood *
- 1996 Richard Schnuer
- 1997 Stan Helgerson
- 1998 Spiro Hountalas
- 1999 David Cook
- 2000 Gary Szott
- 2001 Mary Dankowski
- 2002 Jeff Rowitz
- 2003 Brian Barnes
- 2004 Brian Caputo
- 2005 Kathryn Booth
- 2006 Robert Fialkowski
- 2007 Mark Nannini
- 2008 Dallas Whitford
- 2009 Rita A. Trainor
- 2010 Tom Kuehne
- 2011 Sue Stanish
- 2012 Kim Auchstetter
- 2013 Scott Bordui
- 2014 Scott Anderson
- 2015 Rita Kruse
- 2016 Stephanie Masson
- 2017 Christopher Minick
- 2018 Melissa Gallagher
- 2019 Bill Hannah
- 2020 Kevin Wachtel
- 2021 William McCarty II
- 2022 John Harrington
- 2023 Elizabeth Holleb
- 2024 Nikki Larson
* Denotes deceased